Credit card fees and charges.
Be careful, very careful, when it comes to cheap deals on plastic.
Intense competition among Australia's credit card issuers means some have
dropped the interest rate they charge on balance transfers to zero for six
months.
It's a seductive offer: if you have a big debt on a credit card, you can move it
to a new credit card and pay no interest on the existing debt for a limited
period.
But, unsurprisingly, all is not quite as it seems. Consumers should be aware
how, rather than solve their debt problems, the credit cards can significantly
add to them.
For a start, all the credit cards revert to a higher interest rate after the
"honeymoon" period and some impose draconian penalty fees for late payments, or
a breach of your spending limit.
Also, new purchases are charged at either the "revert", or another higher rate,
from day one, adding to the complexity.
Significantly, most credit card issuers ensure that the "zero interest rate
debt", or balance transfer debt, is paid off first.
This leaves new purchases to incur hefty interest costs. This is because monthly
payments are applied only to the balance transfer, until it is cleared, leaving
the new transactions to clock up interest over a longer period, and at a higher
rate. So rather than help the situation, such credit cards can exacerbate
things.
(HSBC is an exception to this rule. It allows its credit card holders to pay off
the most expensive debt first on their credit card debt.)
Such credit cards work well for people who use them to pay off the balance
transfer entirely before using their cards again. Even then, it is important to
check on the revert rate which may be as low 9.99 per cent at Aussie Home Loans
or as high as 16.99 per cent at BankWest.
Similarly, consumers who make only minimum repayments are asking for trouble.
Credit counsellors say very low minimum repayment requirements, some at 2 per
cent, make paying off a card almost impossible.
They are also concerned that the proliferation of "zero interest" offers
significantly increase the overall debt burdens consumers face.
Researchers in the US have found that if consumers avoided "incurring excessive
debts they would be better off - but firms promoting remedies would not".
A "remedy", such as a new credit card that allows you to pay your existing debt
off at a lower interest rate, reassures consumers that high debt levels are not
a major concern, say three professors in a paper published by the Wharton School
of the University of Pennsylvania.
"Consumers seize upon the 'remedy' and reason that it reduces the perceived risk
and gives license to further risky behaviour. What's needed is for consumers to
be more savvy and for government regulators to pay more attention to remedy
advertisers and the claims they are making," their paper states.
"Generally, low balance transfer deals are designed to capture those people who
don't pay their balance off," says Carolyn Bond, the manager of Victoria's
Consumer Credit Legal Service. "There is about $30 billion owing on credit cards
in Australia. About two-thirds of that is interest-bearing, and that debt is
held by about one-third of credit card customers.
"The industry is chasing those customers," she says.
Bond says very small minimum repayments mean people acquire more and more debt,
and the smaller the repayment, the more profitable the card is for the card
issuer.
Steve Worthington, a professor at the Faculty of Business and Economics at
Monash University, says: "You have to look very carefully at the terms and
conditions on these cards.
"Balance transfers at low rates can be attractive. But they build debt and they
suit the card-issuer."
Worthington says the sudden growth in cards that offer a zero, or very low,
interest-rate on balance transfers reflects the fragmentation of the Australian
credit card market. These offers have been popular in the US and Britain for
some time, he says. In Australia, what lies behind the marketing ploy of zero
interest is a bid to "capture cardholders who then run as big a balance on their
cards as possible".
GE Money Direct's managing director, Mike Cutter, says the new GE Low Rate
MasterCard is aimed at people who don't pay off their credit card debt each
month.
The GE low rate card offers a zero interest rate on balance transfers for the
first six months. After that, the rate reverts to 10.99 per cent. Any new
purchases made with the card attract interest at 10.99 per cent immediately.
"We want people to use this card for their everyday purchases," Cutter says. "We
want it to be the only card they have in their wallets."
It has an annual fee of $58, a penalty fee of $30 if you don't make a payment on
time, and a fee of $25 if you breach your spending limit.
(GE also offers a MasterCard with a 20.50 per cent interest rate. It is offered
to people who "may not have a regular income", Cutter says, or those who might
not be able to get a credit card from a bank. It comes with a special offer of a
balance transfer rate of 9.9 per cent for six months, after which it reverts to
20.50 per cent.)
The Aussie Home Loans card has a balance transfer rate of 3.99 per cent for six
months. The rate reverts to 9.99 per cent. But it has a late fee of $35 and an
over-the-limit fee of $35.
"If you don't pay [something off] your card, then you will get a letter from us
saying shape up or ship out," Aussie Home Loans' managing director, John Symond,
says.
"Not everyone is going to get a card from Aussie. With the rate at 9.99 per
cent, we don't have a lot of room to move. People who need a lot of time to make
a payment should go elsewhere."
Worthington says competition in the card market and greater choice for
Australian card customers is good. But he says consumers need to be on their
guard.
"Cards are enormously profitable for the issuer, as long as they don't fall into
the bad debt category," he says.
Bond says: "If you're carrying a large balance, ask yourself why you have that
debt, before you transfer it to another card.
"Transferring your debt may just delay you making a hard decision about your
spending patterns and debt. It's better to face up to that and change bad
habits," she says.